The Tangerine Tortoise

Welcome to The Tangerine Tortoise, a hidden gem nestled at 145 Russell Ave, St. Catharines, ON. This pizza restaurant might not catch your eye at first glance, but those who enter are in for a delightful culinary experience. Renowned for its artisanal pizzas, The Tangerine Tortoise is a must-visit for anyone who cherishes authentic flavors and a relaxed atmosphere.

What sets this charming establishment apart is its singular chef and owner, who masterfully crafts each dish with passion and precision. Expect to find a menu that is not only diverse but is also deeply rooted in quality. Each pizza features a hand-stretched dough that is both crispy and chewy, with a touch of artful charred spots that hint at the chef’s commitment to perfection. A review from Jonathan Tepper highlights how every bite is a celebration of flavor, with the chef’s daily dough preparation ensuring a limited but exquisite selection. Reservations are highly recommended!

• Signature Beers and Wines: Pair your pizza with selections like Steam Whistle or savor a glass of Angels Gate Riesling to enhance the dining experience.
• Customer Favorites: Indulge in the Meatza or Pepperoni pizza, which have garnered rave reviews for their balanced flavors and quality ingredients.
• Atmosphere: Reviewers praised the cozy, rustic vibe, making it perfect for an intimate dinner or a casual family outing.

Customers rave about the thoughtful ingredient selection and the love that goes into each dish. Derek particularly enjoyed the salad topped with a balsamic dressing and goat cheese, complimenting the meat lovers pizza. Jennifer Laplaige extols the restaurant’s thin-crust pizza as the best she has ever had, emphasizing the handcrafted touch and fresh ingredients that elevate every bite into an experience rather than just a meal.

The ambiance is described as cozy and welcoming, a space where you can feel the warmth of the staff and the careful crafting of the menu in every detail. Whether you're savoring a hot slice or enjoying a delightful chat with the chef, a visit to The Tangerine Tortoise promises a memorable experience that lingers long after the last bite.

In a world filled with pizza joints, The Tangerine Tortoise stands out as a beacon for pizza lovers. Don’t forget to make a reservation to ensure you can savor this unique experience for yourself!